A few days ago I received the following letter from a dear friend of mine. I have changed the names and some details as his discussion is ongoing. I hope my answer can help you if you are deciding between two employers.
Larry,
I have a question for you. Maybe something for you to blog about...
As you know, I am talking to Company A and Company B, and although nothing is concrete yet, my mind can't stop comparing both companies as future career possibilities for me. So far, I see the following picture:
Company A - positive
- It is the coolest company
- It involves a large territory, more than my own country
- It is a company always thinking the future
- People are cool
Company A - negative
- Lack of focus: they want everything for everything
- The business is not implemented in the territory and nobody really knows when it will be.
- It is an engineering company. The business side seems to be tolerated sometimes.
- People are very individualistic, even though bonded as a group
- Too worried if you are cool and could fit "the group" - this goes too close to "You are your job and not yourself"
Company B - positive
- It is a corporation and commercial company. Efficiency comes before coolness
- Absolutely focused. It is very clear what they want from you
- They are opening up in my country offering a blue ocean for their first employees
- Direct International and closer supervision
- Company B is a lot more about my passion than Company A
Company B – negative
- Very arrogant company
- Obsessed about corporate information
- It will not be much international... Really focused on my country
- Offers less space for developing your own strategies, less freedom
Larry, this is basically how I see things after two relevant interviews at Company A and one at Company B. But there is one thing... I really connected with the Company B guy. I liked his style, his style of leadership (so far) and how he keeps his personality in the Company B world.
At Company A, I liked my possible future boss, but I honestly felt him more distant. There was no natural feeling that we would make a good team except that we would be cool as "Company A men".
But my question: How much should the chemistry you may have with your future boss play a role in a job taking decision? A good boss on a not so good company is better than a not so good boss on a good company?
What are your thoughts on this?
________________________________________________________
My friend-
As I was reading through I was thinking back about my last time when I was debating between my own Company A versus Thomas Nelson (Company B) decision. One where I would have great security and be comfortable- or to Thomas Nelson giving up "power" to work under my current boss and salvage a company and possibly get capital for expansion.
It all came down to the same question you ask-
Sitting in a breakfast chat at Company A with my wife Ruth, we realized how really "Company A” people were - we walked out of there and Ruth said- "You will be secure here Larry, fulfill many of your dreams- but you would be miserable- they just don’t laugh here..."
I knew immediately that I would work for Thomas Nelson- and frankly it was a time when there were work force reductions, and Company A was sure to remind me of that. But all the Nelson corporate issues went out the window for me- knowing that I would laugh at work with Tod Shuttleworth more than once. Even today, after more than 6 years, we still laugh and joke about ourselves or some distant memory.
So my short answer-
I would go for working relationship. Why? Because you will spend an exorbitant amount of time- more than you know right now- eating, traveling and planning with this person- who do you want to spend that time with?
Make the decision without regrets- life is short - enjoy it.
Recent Comments